Skip to content
All apps

Banach–Tarski: 1 orange becomes 2

About this app

The proof of the Banach–Tarski paradox in six walk-through chapters: two rotations generate the free group (type words, the ball rotates along), the Cayley tree splits into five pieces, the Hilbert-Hotel trick unfolds one branch into almost everything — and finally the dust pieces reassemble into two oranges. Including the axiom of choice and the resolution of why no gold gets duplicated.

The theorem

The Banach–Tarski theorem (1924) says that a solid ball in three-dimensional space can be cut into finitely many pieces which, using only rotations and translations, can be reassembled into two balls of the same size. This does not break mathematics because the pieces are non-measurable: no volume can be assigned to them. The proof uses a free group generated by two rotations and the axiom of choice. Such pieces cannot be made physically; the theorem marks the limits of the notion of volume.

Six chapters

The app tells the proof step by step. Two rotations a and b by the angle arccos(⅓) ≈ 70.53° generate a free group: different reduced words such as a b a⁻¹ always lead to different positions. The tree of all words splits by first letter into four branches and the centre. Applying a to the branch S(a⁻¹) unfolds it into everything except S(a), a version of Hilbert’s hotel. The axiom of choice transfers this to the ball.

Try it

In chapter two, type your own words from a, a⁻¹, b and b⁻¹ and watch the ball rotate along while the path lights up in the tree; a followed by a⁻¹ cancels out. In chapter three, hover the legend to see the five pieces. In chapter four, run the trick and watch one branch unfold. The dust pictures of the pieces are symbolic, while the tree is exact.

Frequently asked questions

What is the Banach–Tarski paradox?
The Banach–Tarski paradox states that a solid ball can be split into finitely many pieces that can be rotated and moved to form two balls of the same size. It is a proven theorem of set theory. It feels paradoxical because the volume seems to double.
Why can’t Banach–Tarski be used to duplicate gold?
The pieces in the proof are non-measurable: they have no volume and consist of infinitely finely scattered points. Such sets cannot be cut out or manufactured, and real matter is made of finitely many atoms anyway. The theorem shows that not every set of points can be given a volume.
What role does the axiom of choice play in Banach–Tarski?
Under the two rotations the ball splits into infinitely many orbits. The axiom of choice allows picking one starting point from each orbit without being able to say which one. Only then can the pieces be defined, and this is exactly why they are non-measurable.
What does this app show?
It walks through the proof in six chapters: the promise, two rotations and their words, splitting the tree into five pieces, the doubling trick, transferring it to the ball, and reassembling two balls. You can type words yourself and trigger the trick.

Subject: Visual proofs

More from Visual proofs

A VisuApp by heyprof: interactive, free in your browser, no sign-up. What is a VisuApp? · All apps