Viewpoint illusions 3D
About this app
Four illusions that only work from a single viewpoint, as walk-around 3D stations: Ames room (giant and dwarf; the people swap corners), Penrose triangle as a real object with a gap, Beuchet chair and a rotating hollow mask with switchable lighting. A viewpoint slider moves from the peephole to the outside view. True shape, lines of sight and readouts show why the brain picks the most probable interpretation of an ambiguous retinal image.
One image, many worlds
The retinal image is flat. Every image point belongs to a line of sight, and everything along that line lands in the same spot. Infinitely many spatial arrangements therefore produce the same image from one viewpoint. The brain picks the most likely interpretation, relying on assumptions: rooms are rectangular, edges that touch in the image touch in space, faces are convex, light comes from above. Viewpoint illusions exploit exactly these assumptions. A step to the side (motion parallax) or the second eye resolves the ambiguity.
What the app shows
Four explorable 3D stations: in the Ames room two people of equal height appear as giant and dwarf, and they can swap corners. The Penrose triangle consists of three beams with a gap that closes only from the viewpoint. The Beuchet chair is assembled from separate legs and seat. A rotating hollow mask looks convex even from behind, with light switchable between top and bottom. A viewpoint slider moves from the peephole to an outside view; true shape, lines of sight and measurements show what is really there.
Try it yourself
Start each station at the peephole and slowly move the viewpoint slider outwards. In the Ames room, let the people walk and compare the visual angle with the size implied by a rectangular room. Turn on “lines of sight” to see why the ends of the Penrose triangle coincide. For the hollow mask, compare light from above and below. Side and top camera views reveal the true shape.
Frequently asked questions
- How does the Ames room work?
- The Ames room is trapezoidal: one back corner is much further away than the other, and floor and ceiling are tilted. From the peephole each corner lies on the same line of sight as the corner of a rectangular room. The brain sticks to the rectangular-room assumption, so people of equal height look very different in size.
- Can a Penrose triangle be built?
- Not as a closed triangle. But three beams with a gap can be arranged so that the two open ends lie on the same line of sight from one viewpoint. From there the object looks like an impossible triangle; from anywhere else the gap is visible.
- Why does a hollow mask look like a convex face?
- The brain expects faces to be convex and light to come from above. The hollow side of a mask produces an image that also fits a convex face, and that interpretation usually wins. The mask then even seems to rotate against its real direction.
- What can I switch in the app?
- You switch between the four stations, move the viewpoint from peephole to outside view, toggle true shape, lines of sight and labels, and pick camera views. For the hollow mask you set the light from above or below.
Subject: Perception & Illusion
More from Perception & Illusion
- Adversarial examples
- Color constancy
- Mental rotation (Shepard & Metzler)
- Optical illusions
- Place cells & grid cells (3D)
A VisuApp by heyprof: interactive, free in your browser, no sign-up. What is a VisuApp? · All apps