Derivative as a sequence of secants
About this app
The derivative as a limit: three sequences hₙ → 0 (right, left, alternating) yield three sequences of secants — for x², x³, sin(x) they merge into the tangent; for |x|, √x and x·sin(1/x) they fail visibly.
The difference quotient
The derivative is defined as f′(x₀) = lim (f(x₀ + h) − f(x₀))/h as h → 0. Every sequence hₙ → 0 gives a sequence of secant lines through x₀ and x₀ + hₙ with slopes mₙ. f is differentiable at x₀ if these slope sequences converge to the same value for every null sequence. For f(x) = x² the calculation gives mₙ = 2x₀ + hₙ, so f′(x₀) = 2x₀.
What the app shows
Six examples: x² and x³ at x₀ = 1, sin(x) at 0, and |x|, √x and x·sin(1/x) at 0. Three sequences hₙ = ±h₀/n and (−1)ⁿ·h₀/n approach 0 from the right, from the left and alternating; their secants appear in the plot together with a slope triangle marking Δx and Δy. The result panel lists the slope sequences and reports “differentiable”, “kink”, “vertical tangent” or “sequence oscillates”. A limit panel works out the limit symbolically for each example.
Things to try
Raise N up to 25 and reduce h₀: for x², all secants settle onto the tangent. For |x| the slopes tend to +1 from the right and −1 from the left, so the one-sided limits disagree. For √x they grow without bound. For x·sin(1/x) the function is continuous, but the secant slope sin(1/hₙ) oscillates between −1 and 1. Switch off individual sequences to look at each side separately.
Frequently asked questions
- When is a function differentiable?
- f is differentiable at x₀ if the limit of the difference quotient (f(x₀ + h) − f(x₀))/h as h → 0 exists and is finite. That limit is f′(x₀). The left-hand and right-hand limits must agree.
- Why is |x| not differentiable at 0?
- The difference quotient is |h|/h, which is +1 for h > 0 and −1 for h < 0. The one-sided limits differ, so the graph has a corner at 0. The function is continuous there but not differentiable.
- Is every continuous function differentiable?
- No. Every differentiable function is continuous, but not the other way round. Counterexamples are |x| with a corner, √x with a vertical tangent at 0, and x·sin(1/x) with f(0) = 0, whose secant slopes oscillate at 0.
- What does the limit panel in the app show?
- For each of the six examples it shows the symbolic calculation of the difference quotient, such as mₙ = 2x₀ + hₙ for x² or mₙ = sin(1/hₙ) for x·sin(1/x). It ends with the derivative or the reason it does not exist.
Subject: Analysis (one-dimensional)
More from Analysis (one-dimensional)
- Bounded growth
- Units of an integral: rate times time
- Exponential growth and decay
- Optimisation: the largest rectangle
- Area between curves
- Area function is an antiderivative
- Sequential continuity
- Rational functions and asymptotes
A VisuApp by heyprof: interactive, free in your browser, no sign-up. What is a VisuApp? · All apps