ESG method cube
About this app
Five ESG methods on the sides of a 3D pentagon — fulfil the combination requirement, the findings indicator switches from red to green.
The idea
According to the app, the 9th MaRisk amendment firmly anchors ESG risks in risk management (AT 2.2 para. 3). It asks for a catalogue of methods: the institution combines several methods, a single one is not enough, and relying only on historical data is not permitted. Three time horizons come on top: short term (up to 1 year), medium term (1–5 years) and long term of at least 10 years, because physical ESG risks may take decades to unfold.
What the app shows
Five methods sit on the faces of a 3D pentagon: risk position (exposure per counterparty or asset), sector exposure, portfolio analysis (concentrations, hot spots), scenario analysis (forward-looking stress scenarios) and portfolio alignment with external climate paths such as PACTA or NZBA. A sphere in the centre turns red, amber or green depending on how close your setup is to the requirements, and a findings indicator lists the reasons.
Try it
Pick only risk position and sector: the app treats this as historical data only, with no forward-looking method, and shows red. Add scenario analysis or portfolio alignment and activate all three horizons. Two methods plus all horizons meet the minimum (amber); from three methods the app shows green. The scoring logic is the app’s learning model, not a supervisory assessment.
Frequently asked questions
- Which methods do banks use to measure ESG risks?
- The app distinguishes five approaches: risk position per counterparty, sector view, portfolio analysis, scenario analysis and portfolio alignment with external climate paths. The first two rely mainly on existing data, while scenarios and portfolio alignment look ahead. Every method has blind spots, which is why the catalogue requires a combination.
- Why is historical data not enough for ESG risk?
- Climate and transition risks have often not yet left traces in past default rates. Historical data shows only what has already happened; forward-looking methods such as scenarios capture possible future developments. According to the app, relying solely on historical data is not permitted under AT 2.2 para. 3.
- Which time horizons apply to ESG risk under the MaRisk amendment?
- The app names three mandatory horizons: short term up to 1 year, medium term 1–5 years and long term of at least 10 years. The long horizon matters because physical risks such as heat or flooding can build up over decades.
- How does the ESG method cube rate my selection?
- Red means fewer than two methods, historical data only, or not all three horizons. Amber means two methods with all horizons, the minimum. The app shows green from three methods with all horizons. This is a learning aid, not legal advice.
Subject: MaRisk 9 — SNCI
More from MaRisk 9 — SNCI
- Report shrinker 60 → 25 pages
- Balance-sheet slider
- Gross / net relief
- Deposit modelling — moving average
- Function combinator
- Size-class pyramid
- Lever × effort quadrant
- MaRisk / DORA mapper
A VisuApp by heyprof: interactive, free in your browser, no sign-up. What is a VisuApp? · All apps