Skip to content
All apps

Hot spots conjecture (3D)

About this app

An insulated plate is heated: where does the hottest point end up? The first Neumann eigenfunction as relief and heat map for a disc, ellipse, stadium, bean, star, a shape with a hole or your own drawing. Without holes the maximum and minimum lie on the boundary and there is no interior critical point (preprint openai/math, family 369). Heat flow with a track of the hot spot, eigenspace mix for a double eigenvalue.

The question

A thin metal plate is insulated all round, heated unevenly and left alone. After a long time the temperature approaches c·e^(−μ₁t)·u, where u is the first non-constant Neumann eigenfunction (−Δu = μ₁u, with ∂u/∂n = 0 on the boundary). Rauch’s hot spots conjecture (1974) says that the maximum and minimum of u lie on the boundary. It fails for plates with holes, and for shapes without holes only special cases such as triangles were proved. An AI-generated preprint in github.com/openai/math (family 369) claims that on smooth simply connected domains there is no critical point in the interior. The catalogue lists the main theorem as formalised in Lean; the preprint has not been peer-reviewed.

What the app shows

The app computes the first eigenfunction with finite differences on a grid and shows it as a 3D relief and heat map, with the nodal line u = 0, contour lines and gradient arrows. You can choose a disc, ellipse, stadium, bean, star, a shape with a hole, or draw your own. The evaluation panel lists the eigenvalue μ₁, its numerical multiplicity, where the hottest and coldest points lie and how many interior critical points there are. The approximation illustrates the statement for individual shapes; it proves nothing.

Try it yourself

Switch to heat flow and click to place a hot spot: over time the temperature takes on the shape of the eigenfunction, and the trail of the hot spot moves to the boundary. On the disc the eigenvalue is double; the mixing slider rotates through the eigenspace while the extremes stay on the edge. Pick the shape with a hole: the assumption is violated there, and the app tells you whether an extreme point slips inside.

Frequently asked questions

What does the hot spots conjecture say?
Jeffrey Rauch’s hot spots conjecture (1974) concerns an insulated plate whose temperature evens out over time. It says that after a long time the hottest and coldest points lie on the boundary. Mathematically, the maximum and minimum of the first non-constant Neumann eigenfunction are attained on the boundary of the domain.
Is the hot spots conjecture always true?
No. For domains with holes there are counterexamples (Burdzy–Werner 1999, Bass–Burdzy 2000, Burdzy 2005). For simply connected domains, shapes without holes, it stayed open for a long time. Only special cases such as triangles or symmetric convex shapes were proved.
Has the hot spots conjecture been proved?
An AI-generated preprint in the catalogue github.com/openai/math (family 369) states that on every smooth, bounded, simply connected planar domain the eigenfunction has no interior critical point, even when the eigenvalue is multiple. The catalogue lists the main theorem as formalised in Lean. The preprint has not yet been peer-reviewed.
What can I try out in this app?
You pick a shape or draw one and see the first eigenfunction as a relief and heat map. The evaluation panel shows where the hottest and coldest points are and whether there are interior critical points. In heat-flow mode you place hot spots and follow the trail of the hottest point.

Subject: Open problems, solved by AI

More from Open problems, solved by AI

A VisuApp by heyprof: interactive, free in your browser, no sign-up. What is a VisuApp? · All apps