Skip to content
All apps

Margin-of-Conservatism slider

About this app

Estimated PD vs. final PD as a 2D distribution curve. Three MoC A/B/C sliders shift the final curve, Δ-RWA add-on live.

The idea

Banks estimate the probability of default (PD) of their loans, but every estimate is uncertain: the history may be short, the sample biased, the model simplified. To keep capital from being too thin, prudential add-ons called margins of conservatism (MoC) are applied. The final PD therefore lies above the estimated one. Because PD feeds into the risk weights, risk-weighted assets (RWA) and the capital requirement rise with it.

What the app shows

Two curves: the distribution of the estimated PD (lognormal, mean 2 %) and that of the final PD. Three sliders in percentage points shift the final curve to the right. For teaching purposes the app splits the add-ons into three buckets: data and methods, estimation inaccuracy and general conservatism. An effect panel shows the estimated average PD, the final average PD and the change in RWA. The RWA effect is deliberately approximated by scaling with √PD; the real IRB formula is more complex, but the direction is the same.

Try it yourself

Start with a single add-on and watch the curve shift and the RWA effect grow, then combine all three. Note that the app’s split is a simplification. The EBA guidelines on PD and LGD estimation divide the MoC into data and methodological deficiencies, relevant changes and general estimation error; the “Margin of Conservatism” app in the IRB collection shows that structure in detail. This app is not intended for real quantification.

Frequently asked questions

Why does a MoC increase RWA?
The MoC raises the PD used in the risk-weight calculation. A higher risk weight means higher risk-weighted assets and therefore more required capital. The relationship is not linear: at low PDs an add-on has a relatively larger effect than at high PDs.
What is the difference between estimated and final PD?
The estimated PD is the output of the statistical model. The final PD also includes the add-ons for identified weaknesses and uncertainty. The final PD is what counts for the capital calculation.
Is a MoC ever removed?
Add-ons for data or methodological deficiencies should shrink once the underlying problems are fixed, for example through a longer history or an improved model. An add-on for general estimation error generally remains, but it can become smaller as the data base grows.
What does the margin of conservatism slider show?
It shows the distributions of the estimated and the final PD as curves and lets you set three add-ons in percentage points. A panel displays the average PD before and after the add-ons and a simplified estimate of the RWA effect.

Subject: IRBA audit (banking pool)

More from IRBA audit (banking pool)

A VisuApp by heyprof: interactive, free in your browser, no sign-up. What is a VisuApp? · All apps