Give-back donation — does it pay off?
About this app
Three routes for the same service to a non-profit club — get paid, waive and donate, or simply work for free — calculated side by side. One question decides it: would the forgone income have been taxable? For travel costs the waiver gains €108, for a fee it costs €220.
The idea
In German tax law, a “Rückspende” (waiver donation) means giving up a monetary claim against a charitable association – such as travel expense reimbursement or a fee – and receiving a donation receipt for it (§ 10b(3) EStG). What is donated is never working time, only a claim that was validly granted beforehand. Whether it pays off depends on one question: would the forgone income have been taxable? If not, the donation lowers tax with no taxable income on the other side. If it would, the deduction mostly just offsets the tax on that income, and VAT that remains due can turn into a loss.
What the app shows
Three routes for the same service sit side by side: A – the association pays, B – waiver donation, C – simply for free. Five cases are available: travel costs as a private person, an allowance for coaches or volunteers with a tax-free amount, a small business, a VAT-registered business and a GmbH. You set the amount, marginal tax rate, VAT rate, total income and the cost share for route C. The app highlights the cheapest route, checks the 20 % income cap on donation deductions and lists five legal conditions; if one is missing, the receipt is incorrect.
Try it
Start with travel costs: the reimbursement would have been tax-free, so the waiver donation beats “simply for free”. Switch to the VAT-registered business and compare: here the waiver can cost more than just working for free, because under the tax authority’s view the VAT remains due. Then untick individual conditions, such as “claim granted beforehand”, and read what that means for the deduction and for liability. The app is a simplified model of German law and is not tax advice.
Frequently asked questions
- What is a waiver donation (Rückspende) in Germany?
- It is a donation in which someone gives up an existing claim to reimbursement or payment from a German charitable association. The waiver counts as a cash donation, and the association can issue a donation receipt for it. Among other things, the claim must have been granted in advance by contract or statutes and must not depend on being waived.
- Does a waiver donation save tax?
- That depends on whether the forgone income would have been taxable. For tax-free expense reimbursement such as travel costs, the donation lowers tax with nothing taxable on the other side, so it is an advantage. For a taxable fee, the deduction usually only offsets the tax on that income, and for services subject to VAT the VAT can remain as a cost under the authority’s view.
- What conditions apply to a waiver donation?
- The claim must be granted before the activity starts, by contract, statutes or a board resolution authorised by the statutes; it must not be conditional on a waiver; and the association must be able to pay. The waiver must be declared promptly and the amount must be reasonable. If any condition is missing, the donation receipt is incorrect.
- Which legal basis does the app use?
- The app relies on § 10b of the German Income Tax Act (EStG) and the Federal Ministry of Finance circular on waiver donations from 2014 as amended in 2016. For waived fees it follows the authority’s view that VAT remains due, a question that is not fully settled. It is a simplified model and not tax advice.
Subject: Economics
More from Economics
- Consumption smoothing: Hall’s theory of consumption
- Market equilibrium
- Central bank simulator: interest rates, inflation and expectations
- Compound interest
A VisuApp by heyprof: interactive, free in your browser, no sign-up. What is a VisuApp? · All apps