Skip to content
All apps

The syntonic comma

About this app

Four pure fifths vs. one pure third on the frequency spiral — the 21.5-cent gap becomes visible and audible.

The idea

Stack four pure fifths (3:2) and bring the result down two octaves and you get (3/2)⁴ ÷ 4 = 81/64, the Pythagorean major third of about 407.8 cents. A just major third has the ratio 5/4 = 80/64 and measures about 386.3 cents. The difference, 81/80 or roughly 21.5 cents, is called the syntonic comma. It is the reason pure fifths and pure thirds cannot all coexist in a twelve-note system, and it is the starting point for meantone and equal temperament.

What you see

A frequency spiral places notes so that one full turn equals one octave. The path of four fifths ends just next to the pure third, and the small gap between the two points is the comma. The Concept panel works through the fractions, and the Data panel lists the values in cents and the beat frequency.

Listen and compare

Listen plays three steps above a 220 Hz root: first the Pythagorean third, then the pure third, then both together. In the last step the sound pulses about 3.4 times per second, the beating between 278.4 Hz and 275 Hz. Compare switches to the view where both thirds sit side by side.

Frequently asked questions

What is the syntonic comma?
The syntonic comma is the small difference between the Pythagorean third 81/64, built from four pure fifths, and the just major third 5/4. Its frequency ratio is 81/80, about 21.5 cents, or a little more than a fifth of a semitone.
How is the syntonic comma different from the Pythagorean comma?
The Pythagorean comma appears when you stack twelve pure fifths and compare them with seven octaves: ratio 531441/524288, about 23.5 cents. The syntonic comma compares four fifths with a pure third plus two octaves: 81/80, about 21.5 cents. Both show that pure intervals do not fit together into a closed tuning system.
Why does a Pythagorean third sound rougher than a just third?
The just third 5/4 coincides with the fifth harmonic of the root, so the overtones of both notes line up exactly. The Pythagorean third is about 21.5 cents wider, so neighbouring overtones are slightly apart and produce audible beating.
What can I do in this app?
You see on a frequency spiral where four fifths and the pure third land, and you can read the fractions and cent values. The Listen button plays the Pythagorean third, the pure third and both together, so the beating of about 3.4 Hz becomes audible.

Subject: Music theory

More from Music theory

A VisuApp by heyprof: interactive, free in your browser, no sign-up. What is a VisuApp? · All apps