Skip to content
All apps

Yau's nodal lines — Chladni on sphere and torus (3D)

About this app

A vibrating surface has lines that stand still: sand gathers on them as on a Chladni plate. Spherical harmonics and torus waves up to level 14, rings, meridians, checkerboard or a random mixture, glowing nodal lines, length measured live. The chart shows that the length grows only like the frequency √λ, no faster. Yau's conjecture for smooth surfaces, plus the counterexamples in dimensions 3 to 5; openai/math family 350 (formalised in Lean). Exhibit-ready.

What it is about

Sprinkle sand on a vibrating plate and it gathers on lines that stand still: Chladni figures. Mathematically these are the zeros of an eigenfunction −Δu = λu, the nodal lines. In 1982 Shing-Tung Yau conjectured that their total length grows like the frequency √λ, bounded above and below. The lower bound is proved (Brüning 1978, Logunov 2018); from above, for smooth surfaces, one only reached about λ^(3/4). An AI-generated preprint in github.com/openai/math (family 350) claims the upper bound C·√λ on every smooth closed surface, along with counterexamples in dimensions 3 to 5. The catalogue lists this as formalised in Lean; it is not peer-reviewed.

What the app shows

A vibrating sphere or torus shows exact eigenfunctions: spherical harmonics with λ = l(l+1) and torus waves with λ = n², up to level 14. You can choose patterns such as rings, meridians, a checkerboard or a random mixture. Sand gathers on the glowing nodal lines, whose length is measured live in the surface’s own metric. A chart plots the length at every level against √λ, with the line C·√λ and the earlier bound λ^(3/4) for comparison. A dimensions panel places the counterexamples, which cannot be drawn.

Try it yourself

Raise the frequency level step by step and watch the nodal lines get denser while the ratio length / √λ stays in a narrow band. Roll new random mixtures: the lines tangle up, but their length grows no faster. Turn on the relief to see which way the surface swings. On the torus, note that the app computes in the flat metric; the ring in space is only the picture. The dots below the line illustrate two surfaces and are not a proof.

Frequently asked questions

What are nodal lines of an eigenfunction?
Nodal lines are the places where a vibrating surface stays at rest during a natural vibration, the zeros of the eigenfunction. On a Chladni plate this is where the sand collects. As the frequency rises, the patterns get finer and the lines get longer.
What does Yau’s conjecture on nodal sets say?
In 1982 Shing-Tung Yau conjectured that the total length (in general, the volume) of the nodal set of an eigenfunction with eigenvalue λ lies between c·√λ and C·√λ. The length therefore grows in proportion to the frequency. The lower bound was proved by Brüning and Logunov.
Has Yau’s conjecture been proved for surfaces?
An AI-generated preprint in the catalogue github.com/openai/math (family 350) claims a proof of the upper bound C·√λ for every smooth closed surface and shows that it fails in dimensions 3 and 4. The catalogue lists this as formalised in Lean. The preprint has not yet been peer-reviewed.
What can I try out in this app?
You choose a sphere or torus, a frequency level and a pattern, and see the nodal lines with sand as on a Chladni plate. The length is measured live and plotted against √λ. Relief, sand and rotation can be switched on and off.

Subject: Open problems, solved by AI

More from Open problems, solved by AI

A VisuApp by heyprof: interactive, free in your browser, no sign-up. What is a VisuApp? · All apps