Adverse selection
About this app
Explore how a uniform lending rate can drive lower-risk borrowers out of a credit market.
The mechanism
Adverse selection arises when one side of a market cannot or does not distinguish risks as well as the other. If a bank charges every borrower the same rate, borrowers with good credit pay more than their risk justifies and those with poor credit pay less. The good borrowers find cheaper terms elsewhere and leave. The remaining portfolio becomes riskier, the bank has to raise its rate, and more good borrowers leave. Risk-based pricing stops this spiral.
What you see
Each dot is a borrower, with good credit on the left and poor credit on the right. A rising line shows the fair, risk-adjusted rate and a flat line the uniform rate. Borrowers for whom the flat rate is too expensive sit beyond the exit boundary and leave the portfolio. The metrics show the result as premiums minus expected losses, the number of customers, the average credit score and the current flat rate.
Try it
Start in “Flat rate” mode and press “Round” a few times: each round the rate is reset to the new break-even, good customers leave, and after a few rounds the market collapses. You can also set the flat rate by hand. Then switch to “Risk-based”: everyone pays a fair rate, nobody is overcharged, and the portfolio stays stable.
Frequently asked questions
- What is adverse selection in lending?
- Adverse selection in lending means that a uniform interest rate mainly attracts high-risk borrowers and deters low-risk ones. The cause is that the price does not match each borrower’s risk. As a result, the bank’s portfolio deteriorates systematically.
- What is an adverse selection death spiral?
- A death spiral occurs when a lender responds to a worsening portfolio by raising its uniform price. The higher price drives away more good customers, so the portfolio worsens again. In the extreme, only the worst risks remain.
- How does risk-based pricing prevent adverse selection?
- With risk-based pricing, each borrower pays a rate that reflects their expected loss and risk. Good credits are then not overcharged and have no reason to leave. This requires the bank to assess risk reliably, for example with a rating or scoring model.
- What can I try in the adverse selection app?
- You compare the “Flat rate” and “Risk-based” modes, run the simulation step by step or automatically, and can set the flat rate yourself. The app shows departures, result, customer count and average credit quality for each round.
Subject: Credit risk
More from Credit risk
- Default correlation surface in 3D
- CreditPortfolioView: macro factors
- CreditRisk+: Poisson modelling
- Exposure profile
- Integrated risk measurement
- Rating migration explorer
- PD master scale
- Risk-bearing capacity cockpit
A VisuApp by heyprof: interactive, free in your browser, no sign-up. What is a VisuApp? · All apps