Evaluating genetic engineering
About this app
Facts and values kept separate: facts (pro/con) on a GM scenario vs. weighted criteria (health, environment …). No judgment follows from facts alone — evaluation competence.
Facts and values
Making a reasoned judgement means stating what it rests on. It helps to keep two levels apart. The factual level holds checkable facts, for instance about yield, pesticide use, gene flow to wild plants or resistance in pests. The value level holds which criteria matter, such as health, environment, food security, animal welfare or economic independence. Facts alone do not produce a verdict: only the weighting of criteria turns the same facts into a for or against. That is why different people can reach different, well-founded judgements from the same facts.
What the app shows
There are three scenarios: insect-resistant Bt maize, Golden Rice with provitamin A and a genetically modified salmon that grows faster. For each scenario the app lists factual arguments for and against. A balance shows how your weighting of five criteria results in a tendency from clearly against to clearly in favour.
Things to try
Choose a scenario and move the criteria sliders. Watch the balance tip although the factual arguments stay the same. Compare which weighting leads to a different result for Golden Rice than for Bt maize. Use the outcome as a starting point for discussion; the app deliberately offers no single correct answer.
Frequently asked questions
- What does it mean to evaluate a bioethical issue?
- Evaluating a bioethical issue means forming a reasoned judgement about it. That involves separating facts from values, naming and weighting criteria, and weighing up options. Biology curricula treat this as a competence of its own alongside subject knowledge.
- What is Bt maize?
- Bt maize is genetically modified maize carrying a gene from the bacterium Bacillus thuringiensis. The plant produces a protein that harms certain insect pests such as the European corn borer. Debated points include lower insecticide use, possible resistance in pests and effects on non-target insects.
- What is Golden Rice?
- Golden Rice is genetically modified rice that produces beta-carotene, a precursor of vitamin A, in the grain. It is meant to reduce vitamin A deficiency where rice is a staple food. Critics raise points such as the amount that has to be eaten, questions about seed and patents, and whether it addresses the causes of malnutrition.
- How does the Evaluating Genetic Engineering app work?
- You pick one of three scenarios, read the factual arguments for and against, and weight five criteria with sliders. A balance shows the resulting tendency. This makes visible that the same facts lead to different judgements depending on the weighting.
Subject: Biology (Gymnasium)
More from Biology (Gymnasium)
- Antigen & antibody
- Speciation through isolation
- Biological membranes
- Blood circulation and the cardiac cycle
- Genetic code wheel
- The inner clock: light, melatonin and the clock change
- The cell (3D)
- DNA double helix (3D)
A VisuApp by heyprof: interactive, free in your browser, no sign-up. What is a VisuApp? · All apps