The three-cowboy duel (truel)
About this app
You only hit with 10 % — whom to aim at? A Monte-Carlo simulation shows: deliberately firing into the air maximizes your survival chance, because the two strong opponents thin each other out first.
The truel puzzle
A truel is a three-way duel. Three shooters with different hit rates fire in turn until only one is left. The question: whom should the weakest shooter aim at? The obvious answer is “the strongest opponent”. The truel is a well-known game theory example showing that strength does not automatically mean survival. A poor shot poses no threat to the others and is left alone at first, while the two strong shooters target each other. For certain hit rates, the weakest player does best by deliberately hitting nobody.
What you see
Three cowboys stand on a desert plain: you (C1) with a 10 % hit rate, Cowboy 2 with 60 % and Cowboy 3 with 90 %. The worst living shooter always fires first, and the other two aim rationally at the most dangerous opponent still standing. You choose one of three strategies: shoot into the air, aim at Cowboy 2 or aim at Cowboy 3. A Monte Carlo simulation plays 1,000 to 20,000 duels per strategy and reports your survival probability for each.
Things to try
Run “Simulate all strategies” with the default values and compare the three survival rates. Then use “Play one truel” to watch single games: one duel can end any way, and only many runs reveal the probability. Next, move the hit rate sliders, for example raise your own rate up to 40 % or change Cowboy 2. Check whether firing into the air stays the best choice for every setting.
Frequently asked questions
- What is a truel?
- A truel is a duel between three participants. The shooters fire in a fixed order until only one is alive. Game theory uses it to show that the best strategy depends heavily on what the other players do.
- Why should the weakest shooter fire into the air?
- If the weakest shooter hits one of the strong players, he immediately becomes the target of the survivor, who is a much better shot. If he misses on purpose, the two strong players shoot at each other. Afterwards he faces a single opponent and often gets the first shot.
- What is a Monte Carlo simulation?
- A Monte Carlo simulation repeats a random experiment many times on a computer. The share of runs with a given outcome estimates its probability. The more runs, the smaller the random error.
- What can I adjust in the app?
- You pick your strategy, the number of simulated duels per strategy and the hit rates of all three cowboys. The app compares the survival probabilities and can animate individual duels.
Subject: Data & decisions
More from Data & decisions
- Anchoring effect
- Benford's law
- Berkson's paradox
- Cherry-picking: base period
- Cherry-picking: base period 2.0
- The three-cowboy duel 2.0
- The three means
- The three means 2.0
A VisuApp by heyprof: interactive, free in your browser, no sign-up. What is a VisuApp? · All apps