Hidden profile (3D)
About this app
Four people decide on a team lead, each holding their own info cards. The balance shows why the group makes the worse choice and how asking for unique information in turn changes that.
With explain mode: an AI tutor walks you through the app, points out what matters in the scene and answers your questions.
The idea
A hidden profile is a decision where the best option only becomes visible once everyone pools what they know. Stasser and Titus described in 1985 that groups often fail here: they mostly discuss information everyone already shares. A fact known to four people has four chances of being mentioned, a unique fact only one. Shared information is also repeated more often and seems more credible because others confirm it. The decisive knowledge is in the room but never spoken.
What the app shows
In a 3D meeting room Lea, Tom, Mira and Jonas decide whether A or B becomes team lead. Each person holds seven cards, two of which only they know. Individually all four lean towards A (5 to 2); pooled, B is clearly better (8 to 5). Every fact mentioned lands on a balance: everything for A on the left, everything for B on the right. Minutes record what was said and what was merely repeated.
Things to try
Choose how the meeting runs: “As usual” lets everyone talk freely, “Round robin” first asks each person for what only they know, and “All open” puts every card on the table. The number of contributions sets how long the discussion lasts. You can also tap cards yourself so their owner brings them up. Watch how many of the eight unique facts stay unspoken and which way the balance tips.
Frequently asked questions
- What is a hidden profile in group decision making?
- A hidden profile is a decision situation in which the best option only becomes apparent when the group combines its distributed knowledge. On their own, each member leans towards a weaker option. The paradigm goes back to studies by Garold Stasser and William Titus published in 1985.
- Why do groups ignore information that only one member has?
- Shared information is more likely to be mentioned because several people can bring it up. It is also repeated more often and confirmed by others, which makes it feel more important. Unique knowledge therefore comes up less often and is easily passed over.
- How can teams avoid the hidden profile problem?
- It helps to collect all information first and evaluate it afterwards. A moderator can go round the table and ask each person specifically for what only they know. Roles such as a devil’s advocate and minutes visible to everyone also help keep unique facts on record.
- What can I change in the app?
- You pick one of three ways of running the meeting, set the number of contributions and can highlight unique information. You can also bring cards into the discussion by hand. The balance and the minutes show at any time which facts have been mentioned and which option they support.
Subject: Data & decisions
More from Data & decisions
- Anchoring effect
- Benford's law
- Berkson's paradox
- Cherry-picking: base period
- Cherry-picking: base period 2.0
- The three-cowboy duel (truel)
- The three-cowboy duel 2.0
- The three means
A VisuApp by heyprof: interactive, free in your browser, no sign-up. What is a VisuApp? · All apps