Skip to content
All apps

Cathedral statics

About this app

Section through four bays of a basilica in 3D: a slider moves from the Romanesque with round arches and thick walls to the High Gothic with pointed arches, flying buttresses and pinnacles, while the windows open up and the light inside increases. The thrust line in the section shows whether the thrust stays within the middle third of wall and buttress. Without the flying buttress it leaves the Gothic wall, the wall tips over and the vault collapses.

Why Gothic cathedrals need flying buttresses

A vault does not only press down, it also pushes obliquely outwards. The horizontal component is called the horizontal thrust. Masonry only carries compression: the thrust line connects the points where the resultant force passes through each joint. If it lies within the middle third of the cross-section, the core, the whole joint is compressed. If it leaves the cross-section, a hinge forms and the member tips over. Romanesque churches take the large thrust with thick walls and small windows. Gothic ones carry it via flying buttresses to buttresses standing outside, which is why their walls can open up into stained glass.

What the app shows

You see a section through four bays of a three-aisled basilica with a 12 m wide nave. A period slider moves smoothly from Romanesque, with round arch, barrel vault and a 2.4 m thick wall, to High Gothic, with pointed arch, rib vault, a 0.9 m wall, flying buttresses and pinnacles. The crown rises from about 20 to about 38 m, the windows grow and the light inside increases. The section shows thrust line, core and thrust arrows; the statics panel gives the horizontal thrust relative to the Romanesque and a traffic light for wall and buttress.

What you can try

Arch shape, wall thickness, flying buttress and pinnacle can be set freely. Take the flying buttress away from the Gothic wall and the thrust line leaves the cross-section, the wall tips over and the vault collapses; the animation is reversible. Without the pinnacle the thrust line lies just outside the core. A Romanesque wall only 1.0 m thick lies outside the core, at 0.6 m it collapses. The teaching model computes the planar equilibrium of one bay without wind, roof structure or deformation.

Frequently asked questions

What are flying buttresses on Gothic cathedrals for?
Flying buttresses take the horizontal thrust of the high nave vault and carry it across the side aisles to buttresses standing outside. Without them the clerestory wall would have to take the thrust itself and be as thick as in Romanesque buildings. Because the buttressing takes the thrust, the wall can be thin and open up into large stained-glass windows. Flying buttresses are structural members, not decoration.
Why does a pointed arch push outwards less than a round arch?
The horizontal thrust of an arch grows with load and span and falls with its rise; for a flat parabola H = q · L² / (8 · f) approximately. For the same span a pointed arch is taller and steeper, the load runs down more steeply and the thrust gets smaller. Its height can also be chosen independently of the span. In the app’s model the High Gothic thrust is about 37 % of the Romanesque barrel vault.
What is the thrust line and why should it stay in the middle third?
The thrust line connects the points where the resultant force passes through the joints of an arch or wall. If it lies within the middle third of the cross-section, the whole joint is in compression, which is what masonry needs. Outside it the joint opens on one side. If it leaves the cross-section entirely, a hinge forms; several hinges turn the member into a mechanism that tips or collapses.
What can I try in the cathedral statics app?
You move a period slider from Romanesque to High Gothic and set arch shape, wall thickness, flying buttress and pinnacle yourself. The 3D section shows thrust line, core and thrust arrows, and the statics panel shows the horizontal thrust and a traffic light per member. Remove the flying buttress and the Gothic wall tips over and the vault collapses.

Subject: Architecture & scenography

More from Architecture & scenography

A VisuApp by heyprof: interactive, free in your browser, no sign-up. What is a VisuApp? · All apps