The right base
About this app
Same number, four readings: absolute vs. relative risk difference, natural frequency and odds ratio — with icon arrays of 100 figures. Plus the fight over the right base (O. J. Simpson, suicide rate).
One number, four readings
If a risk rises from 6 % to 7 %, you can say it in several ways. In absolute terms it is one percentage point, or one more affected person per 100. In relative terms it is an increase of about 17 %, because 1 is divided by 6. As a natural frequency it reads: 6 in 100 become 7 in 100. The odds ratio compares the odds p/(1 − p) of both groups and is about 1.18 here. All of these are correct. Relative figures and odds ratios, however, hide the base rate and make small differences look large.
What the app shows
In the “Four languages” tab you set the baseline risk p₀ and the raised risk p₁ with sliders. Four tiles show the same jump as percentage points, as a relative change, as a natural frequency and as an odds ratio, each with an icon array of 100 figures in which the affected people are coloured. Two presets pick up well-known headlines: bacon and bowel cancer (6 % → 7 %) and a vaccine headline for people over 60 with a vaccine effectiveness of about 86 %.
Choosing the reference set
The “Right base” tab shows how the same numerator with a different denominator reverses the message. In the O. J. Simpson case the defence argued that only about 1 in 2,500 battered women is murdered by her partner. The relevant question, though, was: if a battered woman has been murdered, how often was it the partner? Then the answer is about 8 in 9, roughly 89 %. In the second case, the share of suicides among all deaths falls with age, while the rate per 100,000 living people rises.
Frequently asked questions
- What is the difference between relative and absolute risk?
- Absolute risk tells you how many people in a group are affected, for example 7 in 100. The absolute risk difference is the gap in percentage points. Relative risk divides one risk by the other and says nothing about how large the risk actually is.
- Why do relative risk figures sound so dramatic?
- A relative figure measures the change against the baseline risk, which is often small. A rise from 1 to 2 in 10,000 is a doubling, or “+100 %”, yet it affects only one additional person in 10,000. Without the base rate you cannot judge how much it matters.
- What are natural frequencies?
- Natural frequencies express probabilities as counts in a concrete group, such as “7 in 100 people”. Research on risk communication shows that people judge risks and conditional probabilities more accurately with this format than with percentages or ratios.
- What does this app show?
- You set two risks and see the same difference in four readings side by side, each with 100 figures. Presets on bacon and bowel cancer and on a vaccine headline make the effect tangible. A second tab uses the O. J. Simpson case and suicide rates to show how the denominator changes the story.
Subject: Data & decisions
More from Data & decisions
- Anchoring effect
- Benford's law
- Berkson's paradox
- Cherry-picking: base period
- Cherry-picking: base period 2.0
- The three-cowboy duel (truel)
- The three-cowboy duel 2.0
- The three means
A VisuApp by heyprof: interactive, free in your browser, no sign-up. What is a VisuApp? · All apps