Skip to content
All apps

Vaccine effectiveness & base rates 2.0

About this app

Rebuild 2.0 (preview): live headline against reality, population mosaic with case dots, age structure as confounder up to reversal, Farrington's screening method.

The idea

How many hospital patients are vaccinated depends on vaccine coverage and effectiveness together. The more people are vaccinated, the more vaccinated people appear among the sick, even when the vaccine protects well. Effectiveness lies in the comparison of incidences: VE = 1 − I₁/I₀, where I₁ is the risk among the vaccinated and I₀ among the unvaccinated. From the proportion of cases vaccinated (PCV) and the coverage (PPV), VE can be estimated with Farrington’s screening method.

What the app shows

On the left a population of 100,000 people is drawn as a mosaic: area shows who is vaccinated, each dot is a hospital case. On the right the same cases arrive at the hospital, with the risk per group below. A headline reacts live to your settings and is followed by the correct reading. A calculation panel shows the screening curves, a table lists cases and incidences. With age structure switched on, older people are vaccinated more often and have a higher baseline risk, so the crude VE comes out too low.

Things to try

Raise the coverage while keeping effectiveness fixed and watch the share of vaccinated patients grow. The “100 % vaccinated” preset shows that all patients are then vaccinated and there is no comparison group. Switch on age structure and try the “Reversal” preset: crude numbers make the vaccinated look worse off, yet the vaccine protects in every age group. All numbers are simulated; the app does not assess real vaccines.

Frequently asked questions

Why are many hospital patients vaccinated if the vaccine works?
When most of the population is vaccinated, vaccinated people also make up a large share of cases, even if their individual risk is much lower. What matters is the risk per group, not the share among patients. Protection shows when the share of vaccinated cases is below the vaccination coverage.
How is vaccine effectiveness calculated?
Vaccine effectiveness is VE = 1 − I₁/I₀: one minus the ratio of the incidence among the vaccinated to the incidence among the unvaccinated. If the vaccinated have a ten times lower risk, VE is 90 %. Real studies also adjust for age, prior conditions and other factors.
What is the Farrington screening method?
The screening method estimates effectiveness from two proportions: the share of cases that are vaccinated (PCV) and the vaccine coverage in the population (PPV). It uses VE = 1 − [PCV/(1 − PCV)] · [(1 − PPV)/PPV]. The result is a crude VE that does not account for confounders such as age.
What does the new version of this app add?
It sets a live headline against the correct reading, shows the population as a mosaic with case dots and works through the screening method. It adds age structure as a confounder, which can distort the crude effectiveness up to an apparent reversal.

Subject: Data & decisions

More from Data & decisions

A VisuApp by heyprof: interactive, free in your browser, no sign-up. What is a VisuApp? · All apps