Evaluating automation: LCCA, NPV, payback
About this app
Life-cycle cost analysis of a palletising automation following the lecture’s case study: equivalent headcount, annual cost comparison, net cash flow with the depreciation tax shield, and NPV at the real rate from the Fisher equation. The cumulative discounted cash flow shows the payback period against the logistics threshold of 2–3 years; a positive NPV alone is not enough.
With explain mode: an AI tutor walks you through the app, points out what matters in the scene and answers your questions.
Life-cycle cost and net present value
Life-cycle cost analysis (LCCA) compares a manual and an automated process as a difference. The investment I₀ is paid once, after which the system saves costs every year. These savings plus the depreciation tax shield τ·A form the annual net cash flow NCF. Discounted and summed they give the net present value: NPV = −I₀ + ∑ NCFⱼ/(1 + r)ʲ. Because costs are stated in today’s prices, they are discounted at the real rate r = (1 + i)/(1 + π) − 1. The discounted payback period is the point where the cumulative curve crosses zero.
In the app
Using a palletizing robot that is to replace manual workers as the example, the current and the future solution appear side by side. The app computes the equivalent headcount, the annual costs of both variants (labour, supervisors, energy, maintenance), the net cash flow and a year-by-year discounting table. The cumulative discounted cash flow curve shows NPV and payback against a 2–3-year band that logistics companies often use as a threshold. Presets cover one or three shifts, low wages or 12 % cost of capital.
Try it
In the case study the NPV is clearly positive, but payback takes 3.3 years, just beyond the threshold. A positive NPV alone is then not enough. Switch to three shifts: the same system replaces more wages, and payback drops to 2.2 years. Change wages, investment or energy price and see which factor dominates. The “tax the savings” switch calculates more strictly than the original slide and lengthens the payback.
Frequently asked questions
- How do you calculate the NPV of an investment?
- Discount all future net cash flows to today at the cost of capital, add them up and subtract the initial investment. A residual value at the end is added in the final year. A positive NPV means the investment earns more than the cost of capital.
- What is the discounted payback period?
- It is the number of years until the discounted cash inflows have recovered the investment. Unlike simple payback it accounts for the time value of money. Many logistics companies expect automation projects to pay back within two to three years.
- Why use a real interest rate?
- If all costs are stated in today’s prices, they contain no inflation. The interest rate must then also be adjusted for inflation, or future savings are discounted too heavily. The Fisher relation is 1 + i = (1 + r)(1 + π).
- What assumptions does the app make?
- The system palletizes 500 parcels per hour, a person 250. Depreciation is straight-line to the residual value, and vacation days increase the staff needed per position. All assumptions are listed in the info panel, and some can be switched.
Subject: Technical logistics & intralogistics
More from Technical logistics & intralogistics
- Flow lab: throughput, WIP, cycle time
- Conveyor atlas 3D
- AGV fleet sizing
- AGV navigation 3D
- Palletising cell 3D
- Control loop lab: cruise control on a hill
- Robot kinematics & workspace (3D)
- Tugger train planner 3D
A VisuApp by heyprof: interactive, free in your browser, no sign-up. What is a VisuApp? · All apps